Objectives
“Forks” and “airdrops” provide new channel for delivering real value
to holders of existing digital assets. The deployment of new forks and airdrops has
raised questions about how Finotora Market customers can expect to receive
or not receive this value for themselves or for their customers. Each fork or airdrop
faces unique technical, security and liquidity challenges.
This document sets out Finotora Market’s policy on how to handle forks
and airdrops for its customers.
Goals
Security
Finotora Market’s primary goal is always security and safety of assets
under its custody. Finotora Market will never introduce support for any fork where Finotora Market, at its sole discretion, believes it may be unsafe to do so.
Preservation of Value
Finotora Market also intends to preserve value for its customers. When
forks occur with significant value, Finotora Market will work with customers to attempt to
deliver that new value to customers. This may or may not mean that Finotora Market can support the token as a fully featured wallet with all the security principles
that Finotora Market generally tries to maintain. It may mean that Finotora Market provides
customers with tools such that they can access the
token and convert it to other forms of value.
Forks and Airdrops
Definitions
- Fork: a Fork is a new form of digital currency that emerges when a group of people decide to apply a new consensus layer to an existing blockchain. The result is the creation of a new blockchain, which can be very similar to or very different from the original blockchain.
- Airdrop: an Airdrop is when a digital currency blockchain issues a new asset using known public keys or addresses from another blockchain, such that holders of private keys from the original blockchain may access value on the “airdropped” blockchain.
For the purposes of this policy, Finotora Market treats forks and
airdrops similarly. Finotora Market customers generally desire to have access to all value
which they may be able to access, and whether the new value is delivered via
a fork or an airdrop, the evaluation and support of that new value by Finotora Market will be
determined by this policy.
Policy Considerations
Finotora Market will take into account the following five factors before
they arrive at a decision of how to handle a fork or airdrop: (1) technical stability;
(2) market capitalization; (3) liquidity; (4) cost; and (5) timing.
(1) Technical Stability
As security is always our most important goal, the technical
evaluation of any new fork or airdrop is critical. In order for Finotora Market to support a
fork, Finotora Market must believe that the new fork is technically stable and
secure. This determination will be made based on many factors, including but not limited
to:
- The technical team creating the fork
- Whether the fork provides replay protection from the original fork
- Whether the fork provides wipeout-protection from the original fork
- The strength new fork’s validator / mining capacity
(2) Market Capitalization
In order for Finotora Market to consider support for a new fork or
airdrop, the value within the fork or airdrop must be significant. If it is not
measurable on top-10 exchanges to be more than US$100M of value globally, Finotora Market will likely not support the fork or airdrop. Note that in many cases, a new fork or
airdrop may appear to have sufficient market capitalization to be supported, but it may
not have sufficient liquidity (see below).
(3) Liquidity
Other than having sufficient market value, the forked token must
have sufficient liquidity. A fork of Bitcoin, for example, with even a US$10/token
valuation would have over a US$190,000,000 market capitalization. However,
if it is thinly traded, access to the value of the token would be a mirage to Finotora Market’s customers.
In order for Finotora Market to support the token, there must be
sufficient liquidity in the market on reputable exchanges for a sustained period of
time. Generally speaking, Finotora Market would expect to find at least US$25 million
of daily liquidity available on well-known and trustworthy exchanges for a period of not
less than 14 days before Finotora Market will consider whether the forked token has
sufficient liquidity and real value.
(4) Cost
There is considerable overhead in supporting new tokens. Once Finotora Market issues wallets for a token, Finotora Market supports that token and blockchain
essentially forever. Some forks are seemingly simple for Finotora Market to support.
For example, if a forked token is technologically the same as the original, the cost for
supporting the new token may be relatively low.
At the same time, some forks or airdrops may be technologically very
different from the existing supported tokens. For instance, new airdrops or tokens may
be built upon different cryptographic algorithms (RSA instead of Elliptic
Curve), and may have new transaction formats, block formats, multi-signature features or
other changes.
The larger the changes, the higher the cost to support and maintain.
Generally speaking, if a new fork is costly but has sufficient value to Finotora Market customers, Finotora Market will use its best efforts to enable its customers
access to the new token. However, it may affect the timing under which Finotora Market can do
so.
(5) Timing
In general, new forks and airdrops will be introduced with prior
notification before the fork or airdrop occurs. However, the notification periods can
sometimes be very short, say less than 8 weeks. Additionally, airdrops can
be done in such a way that the airdrop later will “expire”, giving implementers only
short windows of time to claim the airdrop before the value is lost.
Unfortunately, Finotora Market cannot guarantee to support new forks or
airdrops within any short timeframe. Business obligations, developer availability and
cost are all material factors, and security, testing, quality and service
are our primary objectives. While Finotora Market will do its best to make value available to
its customers, it cannot guarantee a specific timeframe when the exact considerations of
future forks can be so varied.
In addition, should Finotora Market elect not to support a fork at one
point in time, it does not mean that Finotora Market will never support that fork. For
example, upon launch, a fork may not meet the stability market capitalization
or liquidity thresholds for Finotora Market to support. In the future, should the fork become
viable, Finotora Market may, at its sole discretion, elect to support the fork or airdrop.
Policy
In the event of an upcoming modification to the Bitcoin network or
other applicable networks that could potentially result in a digital asset network fork
or airdrop, Finotora Market will use its best commercial efforts to provide the value
of the forked digital asset to its Customer.
Nevertheless, the top priority of Finotora Market is always the security
of the existing digital assets of its customers. Finotora Market, at its sole discretion, may
or may not decide to make digital assets available to its customers. It may
also take significant time for Finotora Market to implement or provide access to any digital
asset created as a result of a fork. Customer shall indemnify Finotora Market against any
direct, indirect, incidental, special or consequential
losses due to inability to access any digital asset created as a result of a fork or
airdrop.
In the event that Finotora Market does consider a fork to be technically
safe with sufficient market value and liquidity, but the customer desires access to the
fork in advance of the timing that Finotora Market can provide due to cost or timing
considerations, Finotora Market will, in good faith with the customer, determine a product
plan to enable the customer to access the value of the fork or airdrop such that the
customer, at its sole expense, can access the token.
Finotora Market reserves the right to update this policy and the criteria
for measuring the viability of a fork or airdrop from time to time based on new
technological, legal or environmental factors that may emerge.